Skip to content

Gossip Girl vs. Hamlet

September 11, 2009

A recent essay in The New York Times introduced me to Accelerated Reader, a reading management software system that has been around for more than 20 years, but that I had never heard of until now. Thank God. I shudder to think how it could have mangled my sense of literary excellence and maimed my love of reading.

Accelerated Reader presents teachers with a book list and it awards, or instructs teachers how to award, each book a point value. The points are based on the number of words in the book and its reading difficulty (a formula of [10 + reading level] x [words in book / 100,000]).

Students choose from the book list, aiming to reach a total point goal (perhaps individual schools or teachers establish this goal? I’m not sure). Once students finish a book (or pretend to finish), they take a computerized test. Past students of the program have said that these tests ask “What color was character A’s jacket in the third chapter?”-type questions wholly unrelated to theme, character, symbolism or anything important. Perhaps the quizzes are a good way to measure vocabulary, plot, etc. But are they really more effective than a group discussion, or a reading journal, at evaluating a student’s comprehension of the text or reading development?

What disturbs me most about Accelerated Reader is the arbitrary point system which assigns – I’m still trying to comprehend this – 8 points on a 50- (or so) point scale to Hamlet. One point less than the latest Gossip Girl book.

Here’s a sampling of the points awarded to other books:

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix: 44
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows:
34
Jane Eyre:
33
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire:
32
Sense and Sensibility:
22
Frankenstein:
17
To Kill A Mockingbird:
15
Black Beauty:
10
Heart of Darkness:
10
I Like it Like That (Gossip Girl):
8
Hamlet:
7

My elementary school used a program called “Book It,” in which we won a personal pan pizza from Pizza Hut after reading a certain number of books. We got to choose which books we want to read, read at our own pace, and certainly did not have to choose books based on points.

According to the article (and my peers who experienced the program in elementary school),

Librarians and teachers report that students will almost always refuse to read a book not on the Accelerated Reader list, because they won’t receive points. They base their reading choices not on something they think looks interesting, but by how many points they will get. The passion and serendipity of choosing a book at the library based on the subject or the cover or the first page is nearly gone, as well as the excitement of reading a book simply for pleasure.

I know the points are not based on literary merit, but even if students know this – which they probably don’t – Accelerated Reader cannot claim beyond a doubt that students will not subconsciously begin to rank the books according to their point value, deeming books with higher points as more advanced and more worthy of reading.

Perhaps children are more easily able to relate to and understand some books, such as Gossip Girl, vs. others, such as Hamlet (Now pause to ask: is this a good thing?).

And now, for your reading pleasure, two excerpts:

thanks to www.gossipgirl.net for this image

Her close-cropped brown hair was neatly tousled; her white cashmere V-neck was just deep enough to suggest a hint of cleavage without her having to worry about being sent home by Mrs. M, the headmistress, for dressing like a slut

Hamlet

To be, or not to be: that is the question

If anyone out there has participated in Accelerated Reader, or better yet, taught it – what do you think of it?

Advertisements
8 Comments leave one →
  1. October 1, 2009 2:42 am

    Hey very nice blog!!….I’m an instant fan, I have bookmarked you and I’ll be checking back on a regular….See ya

  2. October 6, 2009 10:53 pm

    I don’t usually reply to posts but I will in this case, great info…I will add a backlink and bookmark your site. Keep up the good work! 🙂

  3. October 10, 2009 2:02 am

    There’s good info here. I did a search on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog. Keep up the good work mate!

  4. October 12, 2009 4:39 am

    Gossip girl wins!!! 😛 (i guess)

  5. Anonymous permalink
    June 30, 2012 6:47 pm

    It’s hard to find experienced people on this subject, however, you sound like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: